Politics

Americans only. How much do you expect your salary to increase if H1B/H4 EAD were totally banned?

Microsoft trollExp
7d

?

112 VOTESSELECT ONLY ONE ANSWER
VOTEVIEW RESULT

comments

Add a comment
  • Facebook public2
    Why would salary change at all. A tiny number of people being excluded from the workforce won't change anything
    7d4
    • Microsoft trollExp
      OP
      It's not a tiny amount. It's 100K people every year. The number keeps adding up.
      7d
    • 100k out of how many? 10 mil? 0.1% dude. Do the math. Are you in engineering?
      7d
    • Facebook public2
      The employed population is 90m. 100k jobs come and go every month. This is tiny.
      7d
    • Cisco / EngIntervie
      EA, 100K out of 10 mil is 1%.
      7d
  • Amazon UUVv22
    H1b is not the problem. H1b abuse by service companies is.
    If there is no H1B, the companies will just ship the jobs overseas. Yes, a few people with niche skills will always be in demand with or without H1B, but for the most part you will see reduced hiring in the us from the big tech and increased hiring in other countries by the same companies.
    7d7
    • Netflix enjoylyfe
      This! It would also lead to US economy slow down drastically.
      7d
    • Pinterest jcsdrch
      I don’t care about economy, because economy doesn’t care about me. I have to pay taxes that goes nowhere and on top of I have to pay for everything else
      7d
    • Netflix enjoylyfe
      You don't care about your job, your buying power, your safety? Dude! Seriously???
      7d
    • Pinterest jcsdrch
      Economy in the US is not for middle
      class. Money goes to rich. If economy is doing well prices are going up
      7d
    • Netflix enjoylyfe
      You need to get a lesson on ECON101
      7d
    • Pinterest jcsdrch
      Selling netflix ?😆
      7d
    • Facebook gEKd54
      Pinterest - that's silly...
      You still make some of the highest wages for a tech position in the works. Do you think that's due to to your good looks? People everywhere else is dumb?

      You are very lucky to benefit from this economy
      7d
  • Yahoo ui-help
    This poll is stupid.
    Guy doesn’t know how free open market capitalist country USA works.
    Please spend more time on leetcode (
    Don’t you get bored watching same shit 24/7 on Fox News)
    7d4
    • Lyft doggoo
      If you’re going to call someone stupid you should really try to present a more coherent argument. Your rambling could easily be described as ‘stupid’
      7d
    • Microsoft trollExp
      OP
      If there were no competition from pouring H1B, there would be no need to Leetcode to get hired. There was no toxic Leetcode hiring 10 or 20 years ago.
      7d
    • VMware •~
      I think it's you who doesn't know how market works - when supply drops the price increases.
      7d
    • Facebook gEKd54
      It will just encourage companies to ship jobs overseas. Most companies struggle to pay engineers as it is (when you exclude the faang companies printing money and a few others) - you cant just pay any amount - the business needs to somehow make it back.

      A lot of companies dont have an overseas presence because of the risk and high set up costs. Once companies will be force to look for talent elsewhere and they pay the initial costs it will be extremely hard to get the jobs back
      7d
  • Google et2nw8
    As a FANG employee? Probably not much.

    H1b and the abuse thereof hurts low level tech workers a lot more.
    7d1
    • Pinterest jcsdrch
      Indians are half of workforce
      7d
  • New broplz
    The real question is which country should American Tech workers emigrate to? Canada? India? Bangladesh?
    7d1
    • eBay Tim🍎
      Where ever oil is present in abundance
      7d
  • Expedia £€
    It would be a big impact to US and boon to other countries like canada, china, india and countries in EU.
    Most of the jobs would be moved out of US.
    I hope this happens one day so other countries would develop.
    7d0
  • eBay Tim🍎
    100%. With most of the tech coming from other countries banned, few Americans with tech background will be the new kings in the land of nursing and social sciences
    7d0
  • Google DesiBabu
    Lol, if H1B is banned, you'll be out of a job. The top jobs will move to Bangalore and Beijing. And the mediocre jobs that Americans get to do today for filling the gaps in high skilled jobs that immigrants do (such as making sandwiches and maintaining legacy code), will also eventually go to Indian and Chinese people in their respective countries instead.
    7d0
  • Facebook bl@ckmamba
    It won’t. The tech cos will simply move out of the US. There is no way they can sustain only by hiring American workers.
    7d0
  • Amazon cryptolord
    Salary will most definitely increase in the short term if that happens.
    Then they’ll find another way to depress wages.
    7d0
  • New IqUF01
    There will be a salary decrease - companies will start creating jobs outside of the US and the demand will slowly shift outside of the country.
    7d0
  • Salesforce hfgnntunv
    0% since it will be more efficient to move operations somewhere
    3d0
  • Morgan Stanley hotChicken
    I feel it could impact the industry negatively and we could actually lose market presence
    7d0
  • Pinterest jcsdrch
    50%
    7d0
  • It wouldn't change, it would just be more likely that I could get hired.
    7d0

Download the app for more exclusive content.