Misc.Jul 18, 2019
ApplejKeb

“Dont time the market” is a stupid meme

Imagine you invested in s&p a year prior to the crash - July 1999 - 1400 July 2000 - 1500 (peak) Next time it hits 1400 is 2007 (shortly before the crash) Then again in 2012. So if you feel comfortable being underwater for 13 years, be my guest and put money into equities. But “don’t time the market” is a total meme saying at this point that has no meaning. We are in completely delusional irrational territory. If you invest now, you too are delusional and irrational. inb4 someone mentjons DCA as an alternative. It you dont mind holding overvalued trash in your portfolio, go right ahead.

Add a comment
Oracle vH4/fg Jul 18, 2019

Whaaaaat? Who is this new import?

Google Geist Jul 18, 2019

You're right. The strange thing is that whenever a winning strategy is discovered in the markets, it's usually arbitraged away until that winning strategy no longer works. Why should "dump all your money in SPY and forget about it for 30 years" be any different? Especially now that EVERYONE is doing it. When the boomers retire, we might hit a patch of years to decades where money is being drawn out of stocks.

Google Geist Jul 18, 2019

Also: I agree that current valuations are insane, and historical data would suggest mediocre returns 10 years out if you invest at these levels. We are definitely in a bubble. I think many techies are in denial, since they think they really deserve $400K TC for writing some Go webservice and launching it in Kubernetes or whatever.

Google Geist Jul 18, 2019

@TiCi maybe spend a little less time on r/futurology and more time here in the real world.

Microsoft pJcW86 Jul 18, 2019

Normally I would disagree with you given this audience but the dumbfucks posting "invest it all in SPY and Vangaurd and forget about it" in every thread regardless of circumstances is terrible advice. Bonus when the advice is don't buy a house and invest it all in equities because apparently there is no relation between equity and housing performance.

Google goraptors Jul 18, 2019

The question is very simple. If you have money how do you want to invest it? Equities bonds real estate gold Bitcoin? Everything seems expensive and overvalued.

Microsoft pJcW86 Jul 18, 2019

Depends on your timeframe and goals of the money, typical questions you would hire a financial planner for, not ask the clueless internet about which is mostly guesses. I am in real estate but most of my gains in the past 6 years have been from real estate (speculation) and equities. I'm looking at spreading my risk to bonds and other lower risk investments and going for cashflow like rentals instead of real estate speculation.

Apple jKeb OP Jul 18, 2019

Most financial planners are scam artists that push users products on their clients

Microsoft MSFTBRO Jul 18, 2019

Yea but DCA...

eBay eyxitsjtj Jul 18, 2019

Sure go ahead and time the market but make sure you do invest when the market drops and more importantly don’t have your investable funds dried out from blowing it up on high depreciating assets when the time is really right. For everyone else who needs disciplined savings/investment growth - keep calm and DCA.

Microsoft pJcW86 Jul 18, 2019

Not a hard and fast rule to invest on every drop

eBay eyxitsjtj Jul 18, 2019

Yeah... these are the same people who keep waiting for the next drop to get in and eventually hit the grave without anything to draw from in retirement.

E*Trade cbEV72 Jul 18, 2019

What are you smoking? It must be legit

Microsoft antartica Jul 18, 2019

Ok, try timing the market and let us know how it goes for you. The concept of "not timing" is to not look to absolute get at low and sell at high, coz u will never know that for sure and will always be disappointed when you misjudge. It is important to have a decent understanding of fundamentals of the stock and dont get ruffled by small jolts in the market. It doesnt really mean fire and forget for crazy long time. 3-5 years is considered a good time frame for long, but I have done this for 6 months or lesser as well.

Apple jKeb OP Jul 18, 2019

This is incoherent. Read my post. If your time horizon isn’t 15+ years you should not be investing in the market now.

Microsoft antartica Jul 18, 2019

Hmmm, well to each his own. I think you can still invest in good companies even if overall market comes down and NOT wait for 15 years for benefits.

Cisco Infensus Jul 18, 2019

Ya bro you have hindsight. How do you know if you are at a bottom?

E*Trade cbEV72 Jul 18, 2019

He knows. He looked at the rear mirror

eBay eyxitsjtj Jul 18, 2019

He’s looking at rear-view mirror and will crash forward.

Uber pkXrmOa Jul 18, 2019

May bearmongers unite