Misc.Jul 10, 2019
Capital Onesumbodeee

HR issue with the previous company. Overpaid me for 4 paychecks after leaving now asking for the money back

My last company kept paying me because my manager apparently never put in leave order after I left the company. Now I get an email from them asking to pay back ~$300 more than what I was paid over the last 2 months. Can I do anything about this as its their fault plus they are wanting me to pay more?

Add a comment
Apple šŸ’codemonk Jul 10, 2019

They are asking you to reimburse the tax part ($300)?

Capital One sumbodeee OP Jul 10, 2019

I dont know where the $300 comes from..? They want me to refund the 4 paychecks + $300.

Apple šŸ’codemonk Jul 10, 2019

When pay leaves their account, it is like say, -$5000 but you get +$4000 because -$1000 goes to tax. But they would ask you to pay back +$5000 so you end up covering tax? Some people said paying back sign-on bonus works this way but I suck at accounting.

New
chaipani Jul 10, 2019

Pay it back. You need them for background checks.

Salesforce Salesforc Jul 10, 2019

This

Palo Alto Networks QtYK33 Jul 10, 2019

No you don't. Legally they are obligated to tell anyone who asks, with your authorization, you start, end dates and your last title. They legally NOT allowed to say anything else including reasons for leaving, reviews, what they think of you, etc.

SAP Crazy7 Jul 10, 2019

Is it even worth spending your time posting here just for $300??

Capital One sumbodeee OP Jul 10, 2019

What do you mean? Do I just give them $300 extra without any research?

PayPal kochikame Jul 10, 2019

Of course you have to pay it back. How can you even think about keeping the money irrespective of legality. As for the extra $300, just question them and give them proof about the underpayment.

Oath Atinlay2 Jul 10, 2019

šŸ™„

Microsoft Tattle Jul 10, 2019

You shud've contacted them the day u got the extra paycheck. What were u expecting?

This comment was deleted by the original commenter.
Capital One sumbodeee OP Jul 10, 2019

What does this have to do with dignity? Itā€™s their fault plus some they want extra? I donā€™t have a problem with paying them back whatever ended up in my bank account.

Amazon Barsoom Jul 10, 2019

Give it back as itā€™s not worth the hassle!! Talk to to them about the $300 call them - ask why are you asking for more ??

New
fObo28 Jul 10, 2019

Pay it back, now worth the headache it will cause

SAP MrDT Jul 10, 2019

leave the country asap and then retire as monk in India from those 4 paychecks