Unmarried and childless: socially frowned upon?

Google
tsukino

Google

BIO
w
tsukinomore
Apr 16 113 Comments

A person in a long-term relationship refuses to get married and has decided to not have children; their partner commits to the same arrangements for shared career reasons, lifestyle preferences, and philosophical views.

In some cultures, this is considered selfish and immature to the degree of being disowned for disgracing the family. They may be ostracized as crazy and suspicious by members of proper society.

(Please select one option for each question below.)
1. What do you think about this couple's type of attitude and behaviour?
2. How can such a person respond in a tactful manner after being asked persistently in a casual way about their life plans by professional colleagues?

154 VOTES MULTIPLE SELECTIONS ALLOWED
VOTE VIEW RESULT

comments

Want to comment? LOG IN or SIGN UP
TOP 113 Comments
  • Microsoft lMQO62
    It goes against basic human nature. But personally I don’t care. If you’re dumb enough to choose not to have kids, at least you aren’t passing on your poor philosophy to your children. So more power to them.
    Apr 16 25
    • Microsoft
      tech.ladki

      Microsoft

      PRE
      Google
      tech.ladkimore
      I agree on the low odds of my bet (relatively higher for Asians than Caucasians), but why else would anyone have kids? I don't see any other reason to have kids
      Apr 16
    • Google
      tsukino

      Google

      BIO
      w
      tsukinomore
      OP
      I feel like some people have kids to try out the experience and bond with others with a similar sense of guardianship and familial patronage
      Apr 16
    • Microsoft
      tech.ladki

      Microsoft

      PRE
      Google
      tech.ladkimore
      You mean bond with spouse/child's other parent?
      Apr 16
    • Google
      tsukino

      Google

      BIO
      w
      tsukinomore
      OP
      Bond with other parents on shared experience - it's hard to "get" that without personally going through the process
      Apr 16
    • Adobe gofers
      @tech.ladki "I don't see any other reason to have kids" That's precisely what your "opponents" are saying as well, plus they're trying to drive home the point that it's not a good enough reason in the end. Just sayin'
      Apr 20
  • Facebook FBDrunk
    You're Indian. I get it. Do whatever makes you happier. Kids are not for everyone. To use absolute blanket statement that every couple must have children is ludacris. Also, marriages are nothing special. If anything, they bring more sadness than happiness to all involved. 200 years from now, I doubt marriages will exist. It's an ancient practice supported by a stupid tax code and the constitution. People should be able to live however and with whoever they please in a free country.
    Apr 16 24
    • Microsoft
      ToopyToo

      Microsoft

      PRE
      Amazon
      ToopyToomore
      iVX372 - “community would just be more fluid”? Really? Don’t agree - people can’t be comfortable in fluid communities when their children are being raised by the community. Heck they are not comfortable now when we almost live private lives!! Things will get 100 times more rigid.
      Apr 17
    • Datometry / Eng LangEr
      I hate to break it to you but marrying out of “love” is pretty recent in overall scheme of things. Marriages are tools used to organize and sustain communities. That’s all.
      Apr 17
    • Bloomberg / Eng iVX372
      @ToopyToo You're assuming that what's true for you is true for everyone. Whether or not one is comfortable living and rearing children in open, fluid communities depends on one's degree of social openness, and the nature of one's social relationships.
      Apr 17
    • Microsoft
      ToopyToo

      Microsoft

      PRE
      Amazon
      ToopyToomore
      @iVX372 - sir, my assumptions are based on common sense understanding of human nature. I am a parent and I know a lot of parents. It seems you are the one making wild assumptions here. Anyway - I have nothing more to add here.
      Apr 17
    • Bloomberg / Eng iVX372
      @ToopyToo I've met people just like you, and people who are very much the opposite, in fluid communities as I described. What you see as a "common sense understanding of human nature" may reflect the majority of Americans, but definitely not all.
      Apr 17
  • Facebook / Eng PureWin
    We have nearly 8B humans on a planet increasingly unable to provide enough resources for all of us. Procreation is really unnecessary at this point.

    We’re already headed towards childless couples and singles becoming the new normal. So it’s just a matter of culture catching up.

    Regarding question #2, it’s simply not appropriate to harass someone about this topic in a professional environment. If someone does, it’s very much an issue that should be taken to HR.
    Apr 16 0
  • Microsoft
    tech.ladki

    Microsoft

    PRE
    Google
    tech.ladkimore
    My two cents
    1. The primary reason to have kids is so you're not old, sick and lonely. Especially true in cultures with strong bonds between parents and adult kids.
    People who don't want to marry and have kids usually haven't thought about slowly doing alone by themselves. That's probably why the OP is having trouble responding about their future life plans.

    2. If you have kids only because of social pressure, you are probably a spineless coward.
    Apr 16 21
    • Microsoft
      tech.ladki

      Microsoft

      PRE
      Google
      tech.ladkimore
      It really feels like the reasons you suggest like leaving a legacy, or a vague definition of fulfilling life are not strong enough to justify a 20 year longcommitment that will take away LOT of your time, energy, dreams, and money. Of course, just my personal opinion
      Apr 17
    • Datometry / Eng LangEr
      Exactly. Why do it at all? What’s so special about legacy ? Why does having a family ‘feel’ like the natural next step ?

      Ever wondered about why our dilemmas are still so very primal in a supposedly progressive world?
      Apr 17
    • Datometry / Eng LangEr
      Also, I do have an answer for the meaning of life. Very pragmatic and non spiritual/ religious answer. I’m just not sure if you are interested in it.
      Apr 17
    • Google / Eng hooli.xyz
      I’m confused. Why is legacy NOT special? That’s about as big as it gets for humans. Or do we have different definitions of legacy?

      As for life fulfillment, being vague is part of it because it can have a different meaning per person.

      Why do some people don the cloth?

      Why do some people dedicate their entire lives to a canvas knowing they’ll die peniless and alone?

      Why did Lewis & Clark purposely go beyond the frontier?

      I feel like Indians are looking at life with simply an eye towards ROI. Children are not just the combination of “time, years, energy, and money”. I dare say that’s bordering on philistine.
      Apr 17
    • Microsoft
      tech.ladki

      Microsoft

      PRE
      Google
      tech.ladkimore
      @hooli.xyz

      Personally, ROI need not be monetary but yes, to me a major factor in wanting to have kids is the opportunity cost of all that you can do with the time, money and energy.
      After all, you can't love your kids who aren't born yet. So why? Is a life raising kids more fun than retiring a decade early?

      Almost everyone has kid's and passes on their genes. Doesn't feel great or unique. I find adopting a kid (especially from a third world orphanage) more motivating considering the impact of totally transforming someone's life.

      It also feels more fulfilling to me to pursue personal interests, traveling the world or researching on genetics than having to lose all my personal freedom and bear all the nagging that come with kids.

      May be I just can't see wanting to raise a kid as a passion similar to wanting to climb the Everest, or painting.
      PS:
      I am not sure if most Indians look at children from an ROI perspective, never heard that from another Indian. Not saying Indians are not superficial, but that's another thing.
      I wonder if everyone having kids is doing it for the emotional support later in life, even if they don't consciously look at it from a ROI perspective
      Apr 17
  • Facebook
    Nevernude

    Facebook

    BIO
    .
    Nevernudemore
    People who want to get married should be able to, people who don't shouldn't be forced to.

    Live and let live
    Apr 16 0
  • Cisco chukrobbin
    We're really over populated. The world can afford for a lot of people to not have kids.
    Apr 16 0
  • Oracle not_larry
    Don’t get me started on unmarried and pregnant.
    Apr 16 0
  • Tektronix BazzokaGrl
    It's your life do what you want with it.
    Apr 16 0
  • Microsoft uyeI81
    I don't want kids & I don't want to marry either. I don't care about these social/religious norms too much, just do what feels right to me.
    I don't care about the gene pool & reproduction at all, rather proud to be able to have a choice and take myself out of this pointless game. The universe does not give a shit about a few more or less humans, we are all just parasites.
    Apr 16 11
    • Microsoft uyeI81
      In addtion, there is an increasing number of childless people, I can imagine living in a community of like minded folks that takes care of each other.
      Apr 16
    • Microsoft
      tech.ladki

      Microsoft

      PRE
      Google
      tech.ladkimore
      If you don't care about being alone, and that retirement homes would be good enough, then sure, it makes no sense to have kids.

      Personally, I'm afraid my old and debilitated days will suck if I'm all by myself. I don't see any other reason to have kids.
      Apr 16
    • Google
      tsukino

      Google

      BIO
      w
      tsukinomore
      OP
      You can always spend old age with spouse, siblings, cousins, friends, and neighbors
      Apr 16
    • Twitter juJJ15
      Ladki, what makes you think your kids will live in same city as you and take care of you? Are you in the same city you grew up in?
      Apr 16
    • Microsoft
      tech.ladki

      Microsoft

      PRE
      Google
      tech.ladkimore
      There is no other reason to have kids. And it is extremely dumb to spend so much time and energy on raising kids when you could have done a lot more in your life.
      My parents have me for financial support just in case things goes beyond their means , and if they are really sick, I'd do whatever I can to provide emotional support.
      Apr 16
  • Microsoft
    tech.ladki

    Microsoft

    PRE
    Google
    tech.ladkimore
    For those who aren't having kids so you are not lonely in your old age, why do you even want to have kids?
    There's so much more you could do with the time, money and energy
    Apr 16 8
    • Microsoft
      tech.ladki

      Microsoft

      PRE
      Google
      tech.ladkimore
      Why is it relevant 🤯
      Apr 16
    • Facebook blueriver
      I like kids a lot, and I think I’d like my own especially. Helping an awesome little person grow up and discover the world sounds great.
      Apr 17
    • Microsoft
      tech.ladki

      Microsoft

      PRE
      Google
      tech.ladkimore
      @FB
      Aren't you concerned about personal interests if any that may be impacted by the resources in raising kids? Like traveling the world, pursuing your passion like research or any other low TC career all become way more changing to do.

      you could have retired almost a decade earlywithout kids. Is it worth for you to work a decade longer just to help raise someone?
      Apr 17
    • Facebook blueriver
      Yeah it’s worth it to me.

      I think I will love them more than I loved anyone before and they will give additional meaning to my life. In addition to just being cute and interesting.

      There’s two decades where I’ll lose a lot of freedom but that’s okay. I have the rest of my life to make random trips whenever I want.

      We are actually saving very aggressively so that we can leave tech after we have kids and get less stressful jobs to spend more time with them.
      Apr 18
    • Facebook blueriver
      I will say that one part of this a biological urge for sure. Once I reached 20 kids went from obnoxious to cute to me and that makes a big difference. Before that I was in the “wow I should probably have kids so that I have a family when I’m old but it’s a huge sacrifice, ugh” boat. The same thing happened to my fiancé but later, like when he was 25
      Apr 18
  • You’re taking yourself out of the gene pool. Your choice
    Apr 16 3
    • Microsoft mdnd
      We are going through an inverse Darwinism.
      Apr 16
    • Google
      tsukino

      Google

      BIO
      w
      tsukinomore
      OP
      It seems more narcissistic to think that the loss of one's own set of genes among the billions out there would be a significant detriment to the human race on an evolutionary scale
      Apr 16
    • Microsoft mdnd
      It’s not one’s set of genes, but a sum of sets. the ones that are minimally capable of making the world a good place to live are deciding not to have kids. If I want to have kids, I will adopt a kid from my country..
      Apr 16
  • Datometry / Eng LangEr
    I want to share a perspective that has served me well over the years. Most things in our lives are not binary ( sorry techies ). There is no absolute good or bad, no black and white buckets of ethics. Everything is different shades of grey. The only constant thing is action and consequence. If you are ready to accept the consequences, go for it.
    Apr 17 2
    • Google
      tsukino

      Google

      BIO
      w
      tsukinomore
      OP
      This is Realpolitik.
      Apr 17
    • Datometry / Eng LangEr
      This philosophy predates Realpolitik by at least a few thousand years.
      Apr 17
  • Oracle kittyka
    Personal matter and lifestyle choice. This is 2019 for God's sake. One should be free to choose to lead the life they want. That said, people will ask you questions especially in an Indian society. Just be equipped to answer approximately.
    Apr 16 0
  • Facebook blueriver
    Do what you want. Your coworkers should not be asking persistently about this unless you keep bringing up the subject or evangelizing your view.
    Apr 16 0
  • It's a lifestyle choice, like many other varied lifestyle choices.

    People asking you about it at work are either socially clueless or just narrow minded fools. Same with people who have to immediately judge your choice and declare it a "bad choice".

    It's just like colleagues who keep suggesting you "must have another child", not knowing you want to but are unable.

    Practically, though, pay attention to your social circle and seek out people who truly appreciate you for who you are. Life is hard if your the only child free couple in a sea of parents. even the best of them cannot help but steer conversations to child rearing.

    You will be judged. All the bloody time. By random strangers. Get used to it.

    I am a parent.
    Apr 16 0
  • Microsoft mdnd
    I usually answer that we are in the era where we can decide our own path, and the old mentality is gone.
    Apr 16 0
  • OpenTable Meliodas
    Why not ask your gay friends for advice?
    Apr 16 0
  • New / Eng jpasserby
    What you want to do in your family life is your own business, and anyone decent at work will respect that and not really care. Your manager may ask about it to understand your family situation, and to help build rapport, but if anyone judges you or treats you differently based on your preferences, that's their problem.
    Apr 16 0
  • Salesforce / Eng namehere1
    What kind of backward shut is this?
    Apr 16 0