Why do people think their life revolves around living in the US?

Amazon
y6y7y

Go to company page Amazon

y6y7y
Oct 31, 2018 120 Comments

Saw one guy say he and his wife aren't having kids in case they can't stay in the US.

Seriously?

What is wrong with going to live in India or whatever your country? I'm sure the pay is higher here but so? Is that all you care?

What's the big deal?

Genuinely interested.. I'm not Indian and I don't get the Indian fixation with America. People seem desperate to be here. Is India really that horrible? Didn't seem so horrible when I went there for work. Granted only there a few days.

comments

Want to comment? LOG IN or SIGN UP
TOP 120 Comments
  • Flagged by the community.

    • Amazon / Eng
      Yolo!

      Go to company page Amazon Eng

      Yolo!
      Yeah, we are more color aware and shades matter! Lol, no but in all honesty there’s so much diversity as you cross cities and state borders that people find it difficult to live in unison. As you can see above, some people have a false sense of superiority. All it needs is a scholar like @LuBe to light the fire and few coal mine workers like @Whyyy to start an all out assault and You will hear the other side throwing punches in the north vs south fight. This plays out over and over again in many forms everywhere. The rivalry is not friendly, people stoop too low and don’t throw punches but low blows. God Bless India!
      Oct 31, 2018
    • Lyft
      aTep11

      Go to company page Lyft

      aTep11
      South indian states (tamilnadu, andhra, telangana karnataka, kerala) contribute 33% in tax revenue .....

      Stop raping girls and start working dumb shits
      Stop migrating to south india for jobs assholes

      https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_states_and_union_territories_of_India_by_tax_revenues

      The top States/UTs in terms of the number of cases reported under Dowry Prohibition Act were: Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Jharkhand, Karnataka, Odisha, Assam, Madhya Pradesh, and Maharashtra
      Nov 1, 2018
  • Apple
    Whyyy

    Go to company page Apple

    PRE
    AMD
    BIO
    Spittoon of Upper Mgmt
    Whyyy
    Why do we have very few South Indians in Indian army or for that matter in any Armed Forces?
    Oct 31, 2018 20
  • Cisco
    jimtack

    Go to company page Cisco

    jimtack
    There is no problem living in India if one is smart.

    The problem with current administration policies is that it's like a forced layoff of the individual even if they've followed all rules. Ever experienced a lay off? Did it feel stressful? Now add the fact that you have to sell your house, cars, have your spouse quit work, have you child quit school, leave your society, close bank accounts, close credit cards ---- all in ONE day.

    Do you think you can do that if you were living in a foreign country and got abruptly kicked out within a day?

    Say you've been working in London for 10 years, made a life, kids, great career. Suddenly the govt goes bonkers and tells you to leave tomorrow, despite you having followed all rules. How would that feel?

    Even if you manage to take care of everything in your country of employment WITHIN A DAY, where do you go to when you return to your home country? Do you have a house there? If not, where do you take your kids? What if laws in home country prevent signing a lease within a day?

    Look, for a lot of folks, it's just inertia. It's easy to jump countries when you are single. But it's hard to go home one evening and tell your wife, "pack your bags, we're taking the morning flight back to xyz". What's she supposed to do? Call her boss to tell she's quitting? Are these people working at McDonald's to be able to do that or are there real time projects and careers going on? What if she's a doctor who has an important surgery tomorrow?

    It's a different issue when you try to deport factory workers. It's completely different with professional workers with many many high stake responsibilities. Maybe this is not evident to you, but professional workers are generally professional about finishing their job. They don't leave abruptly if possible.

    Also, it takes time for policies to take effect and actually cause large scale impact. You'll notice the slow erosion of foreign workers with current policies. Two years into this administration and people are waking up to the nonsense in US.

    Drop in international students:
    http://www.universityworldnews.com/article.php?story=20181005200448286

    Drop in international visitors:
    https://www.usatoday.com/story/travel/roadwarriorvoices/2018/01/19/number-international-visitors-usa-declines/1047492001/

    Companies investing abroad even after the nice repatriation window:
    https://m.timesofindia.com/business/india-business/qualcomm-to-invest-400m-in-hyd-for-largest-foreign-campus/amp_articleshow/66104158.cms

    Drop in future investments within the US by US companies:
    https://www.nytimes.com/2018/04/25/business/ford-earnings.html

    Business conferences relocating elsewhere:
    https://business.financialpost.com/technology/tech-conferences-moving-north-as-trump-policies-turn-off-attendees

    These effects compound year over year. It's only been 2 years :)

    India specifically has been growing insanely fast since Trump came into office:
    https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-10-23/india-s-tech-unicorns-aren-t-just-clones

    The folks who are stuck in the US are here because of inertia and simply because it's hard to uproot your family at the whim of a government. Folks who are fixated with America despite all this are similar to Americans with a rose-tinted view of Japan (and we know there are a lot of those)

    But with the decline in business in future in the US, fewer people would come to the US as I've pointed the trend above.
    Oct 31, 2018 20
    • Amazon
      y6y7y

      Go to company page Amazon

      y6y7y
      OP
      Well, but finance also happens in Toronto, Tokyo, Hong Kong, Frankfurt, Zurich, Shanghai, Chicago, Singapore, Sydney, and Dubai, not to mention Caymen, Bermuda, Cyprus, etc.

      I think there are lots of centers and tech can be equally diverse as finance and banking is.
      Nov 1, 2018
    • Cisco
      jimtack

      Go to company page Cisco

      jimtack
      I can see hongkong, Shanghai and Singapore, the others not so much.

      But yes, it remains to be seen if tech will be truly distributed
      Nov 1, 2018
  • LinkedIn / R&D
    neeSan

    Go to company page LinkedIn R&D

    PRE
    Microsoft, Flipkart, IBM
    neeSan
    Dear Op, I'm an Indian living in India. I was brought up in poverty and growing up all I wanted to do is earn lots of money to pay all my family's debts and give them a better life. I was very lucky to make my way into some of the top companies and make enough money staying in India. Most Indians aren't so lucky and hence the obsession. Also, after a point I feel India is a better place to be. Great food, cheap domestic help and closer to people that I care about. I guess most people are so obsessed with making more and more money, they don't stop to think about it. Also note that there are quite a few well paying companies coming up in India and the "US" mindset is slowly changing.
    Oct 31, 2018 13
  • Google
    tc?..$FU

    Go to company page Google

    tc?..$FU
    It’s not about the tc, $ or perks why people prefer US.

    It’s about basics. If the cops, ambulances arrive when we need one, if people follow basic traffic / parking rules I would gladly move back.
    Oct 31, 2018 3