Tech IndustryMay 18, 2018
LinkedIn90091e

Google HC rejection after positive interview feedback

How often does HC reject candidate that has positive interview feedback? I heard one or two cases anecdotally and want to know if it’s common. I got a positive feedback from recruiter and expecting HC review next week.

Add a comment
Yelp bigfang May 18, 2018

Very common

Salesforce FANGS(lol) May 18, 2018

Why?

Netflix brokechain May 18, 2018

Not bad but someone else is better, usually

Google amaze May 18, 2018

Very common. What the candidate thinks a positive interview feedback, may not actually be like that.

Google EAjE15 May 18, 2018

(Some) Recruiters are the slimiest bunch of liars I have met

Nielsen uh_yea May 25, 2018

^ what incentive do they have to be slimey though?

Google sstrefv May 18, 2018

Can you give more details on the feedback you received? If it was anything like "you answered or questions correctly" it's not something the recruiter should be saying around

Yahoo Yaboo! May 18, 2018

My recruiter told me everyone said I was good at coding but needed to know more algorithms, everyone felt I was good but not great

LinkedIn 90091e OP May 18, 2018

The recruiter didn’t provide much detail. She said the “feedback was strongly in your favor”. Her words. How good are recruiters at gauging the strength of interview feedback?

Oracle G89 May 18, 2018

You might not be the only candidate with positive feedback.

LinkedIn taco May 18, 2018

I'm in the same camp. Good luck to us next week!

Oracle xnnkkug May 18, 2018

I got five positive and one of them is strong hire. Reject.

Amazon shammer May 18, 2018

Why?

LinkedIn 90091e OP May 18, 2018

Did you ask for clarification from the recruiter?

Microsoft Lotl May 18, 2018

How do you know this? Not something that would be disclosed.

LinkedIn 90091e OP May 18, 2018

Recruiter. Before doing team matching, the recruiter makes sure that the feedback is positive. Team matching happens before HC nowadays.

Amazon shammer May 18, 2018

It doesn't always. If feedback is strong, HC is before

Expedia monkey!🐵 May 18, 2018

Interviewed at Google, did really well on 4 interviews and bombed the last. Recruiter said feedback was “inconsistent” and would not be making an offer. Buddy that interviewed got similar feedback. Is this Googles way of letting people down lightly?

Pitney Bowes λ May 21, 2018

If it's actually inconsistent, they ask for more interviews. This happened to me. I know for sure one interviewer really liked me, one didn't, and two were okay. They asked me for two more phone interviews after my onsite

Slalom Consulting oftL06 Oct 5, 2019

What happened after two phone interviews?

Oscar dumb|dumb May 18, 2018

I heard there is a scale. Like 5 point-scale?

Tesla LEETCODER May 18, 2018

Were the coding questions medium/hard?