Tech IndustryOct 16, 2019
QuorazlTa36

New grad, Citadel vs Robinhood

I just finished interviewing for tech and fintech, and have managed to pick a favorite/winner from each category. However, now it's sort of a apples and oranges comparison and I'm at odds as to which one to pick. Wondering if anyone who has worked in either (or even both!) can give some insight. I'm more concerned about the career growth at each. Teamblind seems to say that citadel engineers don't grow much. However, they give tons of finance education, a 1 year rotation to prepare you, and grad school reimbursement. Robinhood OTOH seems like a classic silicon valley tech company. Given this, what's the best place to grow over time? Other thoughts and comments appreciated as well. Thanks all

Poll
204 Participants
Select only one answer
Add a comment
Snapchat wiwiwiw Oct 16, 2019

Go to citadel, work hard and collect all the $$, get out and raise a family, retire.

Cisco koala 🐹 Oct 16, 2019

Collect money from Citadel and aim for front office

Bloomberg zvlE26 Oct 16, 2019

The comp is fairly similar? I think C beats R in every way

State Street Corporation CaNr73 Oct 16, 2019

When Schwab cut commission to zero. Robinhood is doomed to be dead soon.

Quora zlTa36 OP Oct 16, 2019

Do you think this stops RH growth, or will it reverse their growth and allow Schwab and other firms to regain whatever market share they lost?

Citadel BrutДForce Oct 16, 2019

Rh doesn't have IPO anymore. They're not profitable and have no benefit compared to Schwab and co. They'll slowly dying off from now on.

Uber Guiliani Oct 16, 2019

Go to Robinhood, regardless of what happened to their business given the race to 0 trading fees, you will have decent ML eng experience under your Belt. Plus I would recommend working closer to the valley for future interesting opportunities.

Uber @w@ Oct 16, 2019

Citadel and it's not even remotely close

Quora zlTa36 OP Oct 16, 2019

What would be your top 2 or 3 reasons?

Citadel BrutДForce Oct 16, 2019

That would be Money, Money and Money.

Apple sexybezos🍌 Oct 16, 2019

Obviously citadel

IBM bbWI22 Oct 16, 2019

Citadel hands down. Leave after 2-3 years if you’re worried about “growth”. You can also save/invest so much while in Chicago.

LinkedIn bankrupt Oct 16, 2019

Obviously robinhood

Citadel lemonsedge Oct 17, 2019

The idea that you can’t have career growth at citadel is misleading... citadel has a flat structure so you may not be able to say you’re an Lx SWE, but you’ll be learning and growing for sure. You’ll also own much larger pieces of code/applications than you would at faang.