Question on 401k withdrawal

I recently moved to a new company that suggested I should withdraw the 18.5k that I put into my 401k (with Microsoft matching) and “re-deduct” it from my remaining paychecks to receive the company match again. The customer support at fidelity wasn’t sure if this is allowed or not and was wondering if anyone had experience with this. YOE: 2 TC: ~330k

Add a comment
Amazon IdiotSDE Nov 26, 2018

That's not how it works.

Cruise Automation mocca Nov 26, 2018

Never heard of this.

Amazon Microgle Nov 26, 2018

2 years of experience and 330k? How? What is your role?

New
LaQuicaa Nov 26, 2018

Guessing a PHD, probably working in California. Still looks a bit too high tbh

Amazon Microgle Nov 26, 2018

Yeah, it is very high! Hence curious. Im a masters and My TC is half.

Hitachi Vantara DMT Nov 26, 2018

Sounds dicey. Might open yourself up to penalties and taxes. The IRS is not your friend and they watch that tax fence like hawks. Good luck!

Adobe Downbeat Nov 26, 2018

Sounds fishy to me. What company does your current company use for their retirement plans? What company is your old 401K parked at?

Microsoft jnWl50 OP Nov 26, 2018

My new company uses Paychex and my previous account was with fidelity

Adobe Downbeat Nov 26, 2018

Don’t do it. It sounds like too much work and a bit fishy to me. I’ve worked at many corporations and have never heard of such a thing - not saying you can’t do it legally, but there’s not that many weeks left in the calendar year, so you’ll be working against the clock to get it done. If you are interested, consult an accountant. If you decide not to pursue it, I’d actually keep the money with Fidelity - much better than Paychex (or roll it into an IRA).

Cruise Automation mocca Nov 26, 2018

I wouldn't risk doing this. There's only one month left of the year, you'll likely only get 1-2k match tops. If IRS decides to look into this it'll take weeks to months to resolve. I recently had to submit to appeal penalties. Maybe a day's worth of time, but spread out over 6 months. Not worth it for the amount you're dealing with to the ratio of how much your time is worth.

Microsoft jnWl50 OP Nov 26, 2018

I’d be getting the full 9.25k but that definitely is sound advise. Thank you.

Cruise Automation mocca Nov 26, 2018

They don't prorate? That's generous of them. Haven't seen many companies do that.