CompensationNov 15, 2019
AmazonbaHY74

Manager gave counter offer . Stay Or Leave?

Non tech role yoe 8 current TC 160K Currently working in Amazon , Utah and got zillow offer in Seattle TC 250K, (261k as stock grew since offer) Told my manager today and after talking to HR BP , he gave a counter offer of 195k now over email and l6 in 1 year which will bump TC to 220K leaving l6 aside , a google comparison of 195k seems much more in seattle than zillow offer. I am in dilemma as to choose Amazon at 195k , Salt lake city or 250k Zillow suggestion ?

Poll
309 Participants
Select only one answer
Add a comment
Walmart julyyy Nov 15, 2019

As they say, never accept a counter offer. Also, the counter offer is lower too so that makes this decision even easier

Microsoft kericat 🏏 Nov 15, 2019

Utah vs Seattle, stay and enjoy if you like it there, savings will be same. If you are looking to accelerate your career and ready keep leet-coding, come to Seattle.

Apple KGHP41 Nov 15, 2019

195K in SLC any day is better than Seattle.

Amazon baHY74 OP Nov 15, 2019

I currently work remote and have option to work remotely from any place . Buying house is also on my mind

LinkedIn U💰S💰D Nov 15, 2019

You can definitely afford a nice house with 260K TC in Seattle

Amazon ineffable Nov 16, 2019

Not really

Snapchat 🐨 koala Nov 15, 2019

Dude what's wrong with you? 195 at Utah is so much better and you got access to great ⛷️ everyday!!

Amazon baHY74 OP Nov 16, 2019

So true. Houses are cheaper as well

Snapchat 🐨 koala Nov 16, 2019

Also Amazon to zillow is a downgrade and won't look good on your resume. If you move, at least get a F/G offer....

Workday tdf Nov 16, 2019

Leave.

First Republic fakeacct Nov 16, 2019

The problem with Zillow is that they’re getting into the business of flipping homes instead of just focusing on making money from agents and advertisers. When real estate market goes down, that stock compensation won’t be worth as much. If you like the current job, ask to match. Worth a shot.

Discover Financial Services qwerty-/: Nov 16, 2019

Do you trust your manager that he will not screw you later ?

Amazon baHY74 OP Nov 16, 2019

I do

Amazon aminew Nov 16, 2019

Do you like working in Utah? Or do you want to move to Seattle and check it out. You can always go back to Amazon if you like Seattle or you can switch to Amazon Utah if you end up missing it.

New
Uncle Xi Nov 16, 2019

Being soaked in rain water all the time in Seattle ain't worth it.

Fast Enterprises lodoxjs8 Nov 16, 2019

Career growth way better in Seattle