HousingJul 23, 2019
AmazonUUsUsa

appreciation vs monthly rental

it makes sense to buy a property in bay are as it appreciates the fastest in bay area. issue us its expensive and rent you get is relatively lower. if you buy investment property in midwest it doesnt appreciate but rent to investment ratio is better. anybody has a comment on this dilemma ?

Add a comment
Oath Atinlay2 Jul 23, 2019

Appreciation is not a guarantee! You need to learn more about the market. You’re literally buying high and hoping for higher. In one of the highest taxes states in the country.

Amazon UUsUsa OP Jul 23, 2019

I see it happening for last 25 yrs

Oath Atinlay2 Jul 23, 2019

That is everywhere. It’s also called “inflation”

LinkedIn Wiener Jul 23, 2019

Historically it appreciated faster. Doesn’t mean that will continue into the future.

Amazon pokeman Jul 23, 2019

For long term rentals, I look for positive monthly cash flow. Like Atinlay mentioned, appreciation is speculation and not guaranteed

Amazon UUsUsa OP Jul 23, 2019

Nice. Where do you find them ? Midwest ?

Amazon pokeman Jul 23, 2019

Yup. Small college town I went to school in for a couple years.

New
76574 Jul 23, 2019

Personally I prefer cash flow as I don't plan on ever selling any property I buy (at least not any time soon). The leverage, and tax benefits of a loss on paper help. If I am looking for cash flow I'm looking for more blue collar small multi-family (duplex-4plex etc...)

New
76574 Jul 23, 2019

And if I'm looking for appreciation I go for single family. I'm in Austin, though so not dealing with the Bay Area craziness. But deals here are much harder to come by then they use to be.

Intel Act2016 Jul 23, 2019

Crashed hard in the late 90s. Had to chuckle back then too.

New
DuQvV7y Jul 23, 2019

Considering Midwest is a huge place, I can’t answer for all of it. I own in 2 slices of the Midwest: Columbus and Indianapolis. I’ve averaged 10% appreciation in Columbus (Short North/Downtown) & 5% in Indianapolis (Riverside). And I’m not counting the properties I (literally-ish) stole in 2009-2012. Because the appreciation there is just obscene. I don’t know what you folks expect in SF, but I’m very happy with 5% YoY appreciation with a 3% yearly rental bump. Cheers Coasties.