I often come across comments from US citizens on this platform who express their disapproval of immigration and H1B conversations. While I understand that you may have concerns about the inflow of immigrants, it's important to keep in mind that we're discussing highly skilled individuals entering the tech industry. However, what these individuals often encounter in this group are harsh criticisms. Many Americans don't even travel abroad. This lack of exposure to other cultures and experiences can make it difficult to understand what it's like to learn a new language and move to a different country, where you're met with a hostile immigration policy. While you sit in the comfort of your own country, it's not fair to judge those who have made the decision to relocate their families in search of a better life. Yes, it was their decision, but the weight of it all can be overwhelming for a single individual at times. I've made an effort to understand the perspective of US citizens, but many of the comments I come across don't seem to make sense. It appears that there is a sense of insecurity and fear regarding the potential impact of immigration on the country, leading to individuals placing blame on those who have had to endure more difficult circumstances.
There are studies which point out to American tourists being the worst kind due to how they view everyone beneath themselves. This attitude generally leads them to not learn a new language or see the world from a different perspective. The same goes for folks from rich middle eastern countries, but they generally mind their own business and don’t bother anyone
Biden immigrants are 12M illegal undocumented immigrants in the US + Biden wants to bring more illegals. He doesn't want border wall to define international borders. He is actually hurting Americans. Visa Workers are small in numbers. 65K per year across the world at the most. This controlled immigration has been built by the Republicans in 1990. Fraction of the minority population. Yet, legal law abiding tax paying educated foreigners are hated by GC holders and citizens. Why? Because skin color is not white. Mexico leads the race on the most green cards. The family category green card. All the countries on the south of the US leads the illegal undocumented immigrants headcount. Why? Because they are white skin and acceptable.
Here we go again. Always republicans vs democrats 🤦
Yup, independents are not sizeable. Can't including those or hold them accountable for anything.
As a non-citizen you a guest to another country. Your rights and entitlements are not the same. I for one welcome skilled, legal, immigration but also understand it cannot be an infinitely open door. Also, there’s many places on this planet to inhabit and live a good life. We all don’t need to squeeze into the same spot. I say this message more to Americans that probably would benefit from moving abroad.
Why is it always a choice between maintaining a hostile policy towards immigrants and granting them the same rights as citizens? I believe that granting full rights may not be the best solution, but improving H1B conditions would be helpful. For example, eliminating the lottery-based system, which is unreasonable. If there is a cap, alternative approaches should be considered.
I don’t see why the current system is hostile, but I’m open to hearing your perspective. Tech students OPT into h1b allows for many years of highly paid job experience, better than most Americans lives are. One thing that I think is too aggressive is the 60 day policy to find a new job after layoff.
How long have you used blind for? It seems like blind is 99.9% H1B members who either: 1. Complain about America, how it’s not the same as the country they came from. About the culture, etc… Like there’s an expectation that people will live by the standard and expectations of the country you came from. 2. They ask stupid ass misc/general questions that a five year old would ask. 3. They complain about America’s “hostile” laws and policies for h1b when they’re actually enforced, yet the person with the h1b agreed to those. I really don’t know how some people got into high position roles based on the questions they asked in this community. Let alone how they manage to survive in the day-to-day. I think I had higher expectations for this app when I first joined. Thinking, “Oh, an app where other professionals would be able to interact and talk. Great!” But, the app and a lot of users on it do not meet my expectations at all.
To be honest, the structure of your comment is not conducive to starting a productive conversation, but I will attempt to do so. 1. I agree with your statement that cultural standards should not be compared to one's place of origin. 2. This remark is somewhat derogatory towards the intelligence of our members, but it lacks specific instances or evidence to support its claim. 3. The reasons why people may agree to H1B policies can vary greatly. For instance, if someone had a sick child, relative, or parent and their home country was unable to provide adequate assistance, they may choose to work in the US to earn a higher salary to support them. While they may have agreed to the terms of the H1B visa, it is important to consider the circumstances that led them to do so. It is unfair to assume that all H1B visa holders can easily return to their home countries, and that their decision was purely based on choice. Some people carry heavier burdens, which you may not fully comprehend, and it is crucial to have empathy towards their situation. It is essential to delve deeper into the issue and understand the motivations behind why individuals agree to work in the US. For many people, life in the US is not a leisurely vacation, and it is crucial to examine what compels them to be here. The US has been involved in military actions with 191 out of 193 countries, which has an impact on the economy and future of those nations' citizens. It is possible that the US is the root cause of why individuals need larger sums of money to support their families.
As for #2, I’m not going to go and collect specific evidence to argue with you. I’m not here to change my viewpoint or have a “productive” discussion with you. I’m simply giving my response to you. I’d be surprised if you haven’t seen the ridiculous posts in general/misc. There’s some every day. And yes, I think a lot of users are stupid five year olds here. I don’t think I’m smart either, but I’m not over here posting questions like, “How can I show my girlfriend’s friends that I’m rich”. (A real post). #3, that’s life. Some people are born with silver spoons in their mouths while others have it rough. That sucks. But that’s life. I’ve gone through different immigration systems as an American going into other countries. There are difficulties everywhere. Should the other country make it easier for me just because my situation sucks compared to others? No. Life isn’t fair. For anyone. If the system is broken, I’m not against making it more equitable. But there are rules, terms and conditions in place. It doesn’t matter what you’re going through or what your financial situation at home is. The rules get enforced. I can complain all I want. But I’m not a citizen of that country. H1B Person == Human, has human rights. H1B Person != Citizen of the country
Tell me you're indian without telling me you're indian.😂
Americans want trust that high skilled employment based immigration system is fair for them. Right now it's not and I know that as someone who went through it. The system is just abused. You seriously think these companies can't find anyone in America other than the dude from India to do an L4 job? What a joke. They deliberately rig the process to discriminate against Americans. Tech companies have been sued for it: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/10/19/technology/facebook-foreign-workers.html These companies then just offer to pay fine and the fraud continues. Given what's going on don't be surprised Americans are annoyed companies are discriminating against them in their own country.
I appreciate your viewpoint regarding this question, and find it intriguing. I can understand how Americans may feel discriminated against in their own country. > You seriously think these companies can't find anyone in America other than the dude from India to do an L4 job? What a joke. The answer to this question largely depends on the company's objective. If the company aims to recruit someone who would be afraid of losing their visa and would work tirelessly 24/7, that's one thing. However, it doesn't necessarily mean that there are many Americans who are qualified to perform L4 jobs. The education systems across the world differ, and there are countries with intense competition that produce individuals with higher expertise in math and computer science than in the US. Both Americans and immigrants may be exploited in this situation, but they are pitted against each other. Meanwhile, policymakers stand on the sidelines and observe people fighting each other. American workers may face discrimination from companies that require workers to work under the threat of losing their jobs. Immigrants may be put to work without the right to vote and can face a 60-day limit on their stay if they lose their jobs.
With 300k L3 offers going around can’t imagine what the unsuppressed salary would’ve been
This is not harsh reality of Americans. This is harsh reality of humans 😀 if the roles were reversed, brown people would do the same. In the beginning the brown people would of course hold the white skin in high regard but once they have emo gh walking around, playing around and working with them the whiteness would wear off and the implicit human bias would come in. White america is/was ok as long as the brown people are cleaning tables, washing bathrooms, landscaping the yard etc. When the brown people climb up to be in the same workplace, live in the same neighborhood that's when the issue begins. And this would be the same if the roles were reversed.
This is indeed an intriguing thought to consider. The US has strategically utilized its military and financial resources, becoming the world's largest arms dealer and using its economic might to attain its superpower status. If India held the same success as the US, we might be discussing the H1B visa program in the context of India.
lol sure OP, by being inclusive and banning Muslims from becoming citizens in the land they were born in true story. No country gives the same level of pursuit and freedom as these United States of America (minus Florida, sometimes). https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-50670393
This is why I love US immigration policy. Admittedly, illegal immigration is a problem. But, regardless whether you are seasonal workers or high skilled labors, you get equal chance to immigrate. US put racial diversity and family connections as priority for immigration policy. There are other countries that use points based system such as Canada, Uk, Australia that emphasize on highly skilled immigrants.
> US put racial diversity and family connections as priority for immigration policy. I comprehend the importance of prioritizing family connections, but why should race be a factor? The US has been dealing with the issue of Black individuals carrying unlicensed guns for many decades. Not enough lessons on "racial diversity" plane ?
Because it is not a nice experience to be the minority in the workplace, while majority are dominated by one race. Also, in every race, there are always be good and bad actors. You also find a lot of very successful black people in entertainment industry.
I would be happy with zero immigration. Too many people just use this “country” as a mine to extract resources from. I’ve been to 35 countries and 6 continents. It sickens me that people will happily leave their homeland to make more money, but not assimilate and actively work against the native population, while claiming that they’re oppressed.
> “country” as a mine to extract resources from Where is the extraction when they receive no benefits, contribute value to the businesses they work for, and may eventually return to their home countries? > but not assimilate and actively work against the native population, while claiming that they’re oppressed. Instead of blaming all immigrants for the actions of a few bad actors, we should avoid victimizing them. Even if one works hard, tries to assimilate, and refrain from complaining, the immigration policy can still be hostile. Therefore, it's essential to concentrate on the policy itself rather than the individuals affected by it.
Meta, a qualified American was passed over so you can get that job. If you are so gifted, share your gifts in India.
Ok