Tech IndustryNov 30, 2022
Appletaxowwka

Company withheld tax for wrong state (CA)

In 2020 if company incorrectly withheld tax in CA but I was living in NY, then I need to file CA tax form to get refund for 2020 but still pay NY in full for state tax amount on my entire income right?

This comment was deleted by the original commenter.
Apple taxowwka OP Nov 30, 2022

NY says I owe money as company did not pay them the withheld $. I read I should file non resident return for CA with 0$ and say it was error requesting the withheld money and pay NY the full state tax

WarnerMedia Lyon00 Nov 30, 2022

Messy.

WarnerMedia Lyon00 Nov 30, 2022

How did NY find out?

Apple taxowwka OP Nov 30, 2022

Got audited

Google motivated+ Nov 30, 2022

How did NY claim when company showed your residence in CA?

Apple taxowwka OP Nov 30, 2022

They withheld in CA for several months then paystub withholding swapped to NY and final W2 shows NY as the state. I only filed for NY at the time

Meta 🍅 tomato Nov 30, 2022

Had a similar situation, but what you said sounds right. Use an accountant to help