CompensationJul 31, 2019
Newydlf51

Cruise vs Shopify vs Nextdoor vs Instacart vs Splunk (potentially)

I have gotten the following offers. YOE: ~15 years. Cruise: - TC: 335k - salary: 185k - annual bonus: 55k - sign on 30k - RSU 350k (total) over 4 years Shopify - TC: 220k - salary: 180 - RSU: 125k over 3 years Instcart - TC: 303k - salary: 185k - RSU: 476k over 4 years Nextdoor - TC: $274k - Salary: 190k - Sign on: 20k - Options: 316k over 4 years Splunk: - Still waiting. Told them that my expectation is 300k. The recruiter said that it's a bit on the high side and will see what he can do. I'm leaning towards Cruise since they are working on some really cutting edge stuff there, but I also heard that the culture there isn't that great. What do you guys think? Please keep trolling to the minimum.

Add a comment
Google shn ghv Jul 31, 2019

with Cruise keep on mind that your tc should not include rsus, or should be heavily discounted. There is chance they don't make anywhere against the heavy competition and you end up with worthless rsus.

New
ydlf51 OP Jul 31, 2019

Totally, agree. Discounting the RSU completely, we are looking at 240k for Cruise.

Microsoft meanwhile Jul 31, 2019

Yup Cruise IPO has a long way to go. No revenue for the next few years.

Yelp sJJv80 Jul 31, 2019

Shopify and Splunk are public companies, so they have an advantage in that their stock is real money. I have also heard Cruise was a shit show just generally speaking. Nextdoor, I interviewed with them, and they did not impress me. It was such a disorganized process, I can’t imagine the rest of the company is any better. I also didn’t think they were doing anything particularly interesting.

New
ydlf51 OP Jul 31, 2019

I'm looking at Nextdoor more seriously now since I know some people there have sold their shares in the secondary market. Also, everyone has good things to say about the new CEO.

Capital One sjdhxyy Jul 31, 2019

I heard good reviews about nextdoor and it’s depends upon team but there is potential to go IPO or get acquired as it is later stage startup . If you get splunk then forget everything and get Splunk .

Splunk Kjcdfjc Jul 31, 2019

Id pick splunk if they pay 330. Otherwise cruise is good too with more interesting tech. Also their rsu is real money too.

New
ydlf51 OP Jul 31, 2019

I'm assuming that you are saying that Cruise's RSU is real money too. Their RSU is not liquid afalk.

Splunk Kjcdfjc Jul 31, 2019

Yea... you are right, they used to offer GM RSU, seems like not any more after spin off

Microsoft FwwQ08 Jul 31, 2019

Instacart is an interesting choice; I’d take it over the others here.

New
ydlf51 OP Jul 31, 2019

Interesting. Care to elaborate?

Microsoft FwwQ08 Jul 31, 2019

It’s a segment leader in a market with huge potential; groceries are like $1 trillion per year. IMO it has more upside than any of the other options here. I’ve heard mixed things about tech there, but nothing out of line with a tech startup growing into a big company.

Microsoft meanwhile Jul 31, 2019

If I am Indian, I would choose Instacart. There is something about working for home grown companies. If not, I would go for either Nextdoor or Cruise. Nextdoor has a promising future with dominance in the space. There are a lot of people with single family homes using it and what Nextdoor provides can be easily monetized for home owners. Cruise is no 2 in this space. I saw some people complain about culture and engineering stack. But this is consistent with other start ups. If I don’t need much cash in near future, this will be my first choice (eg single guy with no kids). You would have many choices later in career after spending some years at Cruise. You want to be in a growing area.

Cruise Automation rotifbs28 Aug 1, 2019

Don’t do Cruise

New
ydlf51 OP Aug 2, 2019

Care to elaborate?

Cruise Automation rotifbs28 Aug 2, 2019

They had no cheese snacks stocked in the kitchens

Salesforce foobar1233 Aug 7, 2019

What levels at these companies?

New
ydlf51 OP Aug 24, 2019

All Sr. Dev. Except for splunk. Somehow they think that I'm a level 3.

American Express QBDK33 Aug 7, 2019

OP, Which one did you end up choosing?

MZ mmmzzzz Aug 13, 2019

Which one did you decide to go, OP?

New
ydlf51 OP Aug 24, 2019

Cruise