HousingMar 22
Blockquietmoose

Housing

I’m thinking of buying a 1.2M house. Is 8000$ a month in housing (mortgage + taxes + insurance) too much for a base income of $205k in NY metro? 3 kids under 5 and single income HH. Got about $150-200k a year in RSUs. House is in very good school district. Downpayment would be my liquid NW.

Poll
110 Participants
Select only one answer
Amazon eGvi26 Mar 22

This app is unreal 💀

Block quietmoose OP Mar 22

Enlighten us

Mailchimp unavlbl Mar 22

House is more than you can afford. You need hefty down payment of 25-30% Shop within your budget I.e strictly under 800k Comp required: Total comp = (House Price - Downpayment)/3

Meta whatTooDo Mar 22

Is this a ballpark number people generally agree on? Being conservative I guess?

Mailchimp unavlbl Mar 22

With this you are already taking 3X leverage. Beyond that is insane especially on single household income

Instacart akshully Mar 22

This is tight. After housing, you have about $2k a month from base, then you need the RSU for the basic living expense.

Apple yKT24n Mar 22

What home are you able to buy for 1.2M in NY metro? 🤔

Google fr28dkL Mar 22

Here’s some comparison for thought My wife and I combined make 400k base, and 350k in stock. HH TC is 800k with bonus. We have a mortgage payment of $6400 a month, two cars at about $1200k, daycare at about $3000, and remaining bills+meals+travel+shopping at about $4000 We’re barely saving. Luckily we don’t have to sell RSU to monthly expenses. And every year, our mortgage is increasing with property taxes as well as all our bills. Yet our TC hasn’t really changed. Tl;dr, we make 2x what you make and have only 1 kid and less mortgage payments and we’re barely getting by in terms of savings. Every year there’s some shit that comes up: new water heater, dog has an infection, tires have a nail, etc etc. it eats away. So don’t buy a house and have like no money left. Have a good chunk left over for these creeping expenses

Lyft ei3snw Mar 22

Thanks for the details. I'm single and spend 6000$ a month including travel every few months. I pay 3.5k in rent living in San Francisco. Looks like I need to save some money

Meta 👋 mate Mar 22

Kind of interesting how varied peoples money habits are. I have 2 kids. Make around 500k a year and our hh expenses are 7-8k. I rent 3.5k and live in the east bay.

Upwork sf3 Mar 22

How will you manage an unfortunate event like a layoff?

Oracle OCIdgaf Mar 22

It’s too much on your current picture - but if inflation sticks then it won’t be too much in 10 years when you are making 400k base (and everything costs way more, but how else will the govts of the world get out of stifling debt and spending than by borrowing and printing?). People are starting to gamble on this growing probability… good luck!

Upwork sf3 Mar 22

Can you explain this further

Meta n0pw6 Mar 22

Don't do it, just rent

Block quietmoose OP Mar 26

Not a chance. We’re done renting.

Block riofkote Mar 22

You know how Block stock is volatile. Don't count on it much. I'm in 2 income household, with TC 800k and 1 kid. The best decision ever was to get a property with $4k monthly mortgage payment. When my partner was laid off we still were able to pay all our expenses+mortgage+preschool. Even with household TC of 800k I wouldn't have risked 8k/mo mortgage.

Stripe TheMarket Mar 22

So is your advice to build a time machine, go back to ZIRP, and buy a house then?

Amazon anzn Mar 26

HH TC: $340k base, + $30-$40k on bonus and RSU… going for $7.5k mortgage with 20% down on a $1.25M home in WA.

Block quietmoose OP Mar 26

How many RSUs?

Amazon anzn Mar 26

RSUs are less than $15k a year… heavy on base and bonus. I don’t work at Amazon anymore FYI.