Misc.Feb 6, 2023

Zillow vs. Redfin

Zillow and Redfin used to have wildly different estimates on the same houses. Over the past year, I have noticed that their estimates have been converging to become very similar. What’s behind that?

VMware hbuJ42 Feb 6, 2023

Both using the same unappropriate library

ByteDance 🎶🎵tictic Feb 6, 2023

Inappropriate*

Amazon smexylexi Feb 6, 2023

One of them is just calling the other’s API

Noom Schistic Feb 6, 2023

One of them (I believe redfin) reacts faster to changing market - right or wrong. When market is slower, gives time to catch up and equalize.

Zillow Group rich b pls Feb 6, 2023

For on-market or off-market? Zillow at least has separate models and iirc on-market takes listing price as a fairly heavily weighted feature

New
can't code Feb 6, 2023

Zillow has better UI and more discount

GSK gsom Feb 6, 2023

Zillow has an honest estimate history, but Redfin shifts the whole curve

Meta notauser2 Feb 6, 2023

Who cares. Online estimates are meaningless and only accurate plus or minus a million dollars at best lol.

VMware jH7X55A Feb 6, 2023

According to a real estate agent I know the Zillow/Redfin estimates do affect the market.

Meta notauser2 Feb 6, 2023

That's would be comical. We already know it doesn't though, just ask zillows ibuyer program

Microsoft blindpew Feb 6, 2023

The cost function was incorrect for one of them, just kidding 😂

Okta ema911 Feb 6, 2023

I don’t understand why can’t Zillow Redfin modify their zestimate algorithm to look at last 30-45 days “sold” price in the zipcode for “similar” type houses rather than ridiculous zestimates which no realtor/agent anyways cares.

Zillow Group rich b pls Feb 6, 2023

What do you think the Zestimate entails, if not that

Intel owjsnw17 Feb 6, 2023

Look at what happened to Zillow’s house flipping business. Their algorithms are a joke.

Zillow Group rich b pls Feb 6, 2023

https://notoriousrob.com/2021/11/project-ketchup-ibuying-is-just-fine-zillow-was-not/ I'll just leave this here because I've explained this dozens of times by now