The rs3 is one of the funnest things I’ve ever driven. Handling is incredible and it’s so so fast
Rs3
Why are you boxing yourself between these two? Get an M2
I don’t like the new boxy design
They're not even in the same segment. I'm assuming you don't know much about cars. So go with m440i.
rs3
M440i is not a full M. RS3 is comparable to a M2/3. If you're not looking for a true performance car but rather something in the middle of performance and luxury, go with the M440i.
Is M440i even good? Something worth getting over M340i for the additional $$? Going proper M is obviously the better choice. @OP. Between the two you mentioned, I’d get the RS3
I haven't driven the M440i so I can't say. I own a M340i though, and I think it's one of the best daily drivers you can get.
Both, why choose
VAG fanboy, have a heavily modified S3. Would +1 the RS3 if you don't mind the more compact interior. The M440i would give you a lot more space but ultimately depends upon your situation and what you want to use it for.
Between those, RS3 for sure. But be aware that maintenance on RS models can be stupid expensive. More expensive than Porsche maintenance
Both sucks