Tech IndustryMar 7, 2018
VMwarecnYR72

Ever got rejected despite being the top candidate for a position?

Recently interviewed with a AI chip major based in Santa Clara. After the due rounds of interview, was notified that I was the top candidate. When the top candidate however asked for a top notch billing and TC, the Sr. Director flipped apparently. Strongly believe my requirements were within the band for the position , at the max of the band. After silly dallying for a couple of days HR got back saying you are pricey and we will go with the cheaper alternative. BTW the salary ranges were never discussed until all interviews were over and I went with Glassdoor/Paysa suggestions. So my question is how do you handle such situations and get HR to understand that with high quality comes high price?

Amazon AMAZ Mar 7, 2018

Why would a company reject a top candidate for a position would be a better question

Apple Prlitbamni Mar 7, 2018

For the sake of diversity. Its common-place nowadays.

Lyft pooof Mar 8, 2018

Could also be salary. A government job really wanted me but couldn't get close to what I was being paid.

eBay #yolo Mar 7, 2018

AI chip major manufacturer in Santa Clara? Nvidia?

Amazon JezzBefos Mar 7, 2018

No, the other one

Amazon Hooliganss Mar 7, 2018

Ultimately it’s the company’s call on what your worth. I’m not sure how easily you can change their mind. They probably have fairly strict budgets

Facebook Bruhlol Mar 7, 2018

Hate to say this but I don’t think you were truly the top candidate.

Airbnb bzzz Mar 8, 2018

seriously, why do people believe recruiters when they try to fluff your ego?

Avvo FXbL52 Mar 7, 2018

Weird that they didn't want to negotiate at all. I would just state when they ask you about salary requirements in an interview, "I've researched the average salary for this type of role, and x is a realistic salary for someone with my skills and experience"

Microsoft Techbro! Mar 7, 2018

What numbers did you ask for?

VMware cnYR72 OP Mar 7, 2018

250 + 50k RSU

Microsoft Techbro! Mar 7, 2018

What position? Is this for AI Dev or what?

Oath SerRando Mar 7, 2018

I feel like I’m the top candidate every time I go interview. Doesn’t always get the job though.

Microsoft Nutellaa Mar 7, 2018

Yes for being White

Apple Dpprna Mar 7, 2018

*white male.

Apple JVfS11 Mar 9, 2018

Same for being an Asian male at the end of the recruiting season. They needed to pad their diversity quotas. Thanks FB.

Oath FaceIt Mar 7, 2018

The thing, even if you are a top candidate, you aren’t a superman or significantly better than others. The marginal difference is usually narrow. And if the 2nd best is 20% cheaper, then you are over pricing yourself.

Salesforce Pqowiey Mar 7, 2018

If you were truly the top candidate, either the next candidate was very close to as good - and cheaper - or they felt that it was easy to find other candidates of your caliber who would take salary in the mid band. It’s not a great thing to be hired in at the top of a band, as it will be hard to give you raises at that point w/o promoting you. I can imagine a company not wanting to hire at top of band unless it absolutely has to. To get a higher incoming salary you really need to argue to be in the next band up, and do what you need to do in your current role to level you up so that you can interview and get hired at the next level.