Google vs Walmart

For a strategy & analytics professional with 4.5 YoE, is Google Financial Analyst (NYC) a better position or a Walmart Senior Manager II (Arkansas) in their Strategy & Analytics division, with the goal of pursuing strategy/ PM in the future. Also want to keep company work culture, brand name and future internal mobility to reach these goals in mind. Would love to hear views about location/ brand value/ internal mobility in comments! #Tech #google #walmart #data #strategy #analytics

Poll
47 Participants
Multiple selections allowed
Charter Rambo John Jun 17, 2021

Definitely not Walmart.

Rally Health rh848 Jun 17, 2021

WalMart can be like a fish market. That's what I heard.

Walmart RsBH40 Jun 17, 2021

Are you sure it’s sr mgr II, as per Walmart that’s quite a senior role, often comes with a large team reporting to you. Whereas by my knowledge, financial analyst is a junior role in google. I am not in a position to give advise on this, but choose wisely

Verisk Analytics rookieths OP Jun 17, 2021

Yes its senior manager II but it is an individual contributor role, has nobody reporting to me..

Rally Health rh848 Jun 17, 2021

To match salary?

Charter Rambo John Jun 17, 2021

Again, Walmart culture in Bentonville is Sh%% with mostly managers from WITCH backgrounds who became full time and got promoted due to the lack of competition at some point. They brought their horrible culture from their sh** consulting companies. Bentonville is a boring and tiny place no matter how much they sell it to you.

Verisk Analytics rookieths OP Jun 17, 2021

Thats actually helpful! Thank you!! Btw all the people iv met have been at walmart since forever!

Charter Rambo John Jun 18, 2021

Yes, they operate as a cult in Bentonville. They only hire people under them who they know would put up with their sh**. They are sitting here since forever and buying worthless properties all around the place hoping the real estate market will go up. All they have done is inflate the market quite a bit and made it harder for locals to buy any decent property. One market crash and its all gone.

Amazon elysses Jun 17, 2021

OP, can I DM you for Walmart interview tips? I have an interview coming up for a similar senior manager II role

Verisk Analytics rookieths OP Jun 17, 2021

Sounds like you might be my competition, but sure! :)

Amazon elysses Jun 17, 2021

No, my role is in San Bruno.

Amazon wawY45 Jun 17, 2021

Imagine telling your friends you work at Walmart!

Amazon sauvignon Jun 17, 2021

What do you mean?

Amazon wawY45 Jun 17, 2021

Just try it. I had a friend who was visiting his homeland, and at the passport control was asked what he was doing abroad. (Do you really wanna tell imply your TC in a developing country?) He said he works at Uber. "Oh, you're a taxi driver? There you go, (stamp), have a nice day!"