Tech IndustryJul 18, 2019
Amazonacker

How to fix hr1044

So at this point everyone knows the problem with hr1044 is that the India queue contains a very large number of low quality applications submitted by Cognizant, Wipro, Infosys, etc, and that high quality applicants from r.o.w. would end up waiting years while these low quality applicants are processed. There's a relatively straight forward fix: 1. Add a base salary criteria to EB2 queue, and adjust it up and down until there is no backlog. Any applicants who don't qualify move to EB3. 2. Reallocate 25k visas from EB3 to EB2 so the it's 65k/15k instead of 40k/40k 3. Remove the country cap for EB2 The effect of this is we would clear the India backlog in order of salary. The first year the salary cap might be very high, and every year we'd get greencards to the next 65k most meritorious candidates. There would never be an EB2 backog because the threshold would adjust to prevent it. With the skilled EB2 queue the goal is to get people in order by merit so removing the cap and priorizing the more meritorious people makes sense. For the unskilled EB3 queue merit is not a consideration by definition so it makes sense to prioritize on a non merit basis there, perhaps diversity. Maybe a lottery can be used in eb3 instead of a waiting queue. This would actually get greencards to the best people from India FASTER than hr1044 since there would be 65k visas available. The country cap should also be removed from EB1 for the same reason, but in that case perhaps try an find a way to prioritize by influence rather than salary (number and degree of publications and commendations). Or maybe just remove it for now if it's too hard to create ranking.

Google FGtp85 Jul 18, 2019

Clearly you have high salary

Amazon acker OP Jul 18, 2019

I assume you do too

Groupon huntr Jul 18, 2019

Salary should not be the only criteria. People in the software industry generally would get paid much more than someone from say manufacturing side. It wouldn't be fair to them. A better way would Just be to overhaul the entire thing and replace it by a point merit based system in my opinion

Google FGtp85 Jul 18, 2019

Manufacturing is not stem so that's fine

Groupon huntr Jul 18, 2019

Ok something else then. Pharma

Apple UYgA64 Jul 18, 2019

Congressmen will see this post and make a note of it. Thanks for your valuable feedback, op.

Amazon acker OP Jul 18, 2019

I'm hoping Indians will push Immigration Voice to advocate for it. It would be a nice getting all of us aligned in support of a solution whereas right now everyone but Indians opposed hr1044

Apple UYgA64 Jul 18, 2019

If Bezos was a congressman, he would have asked you "did you take stupid bill today?"

Microsoft hworld Jul 18, 2019

Even simpler algo - sort the queue by TC in descending order.

Amazon acker OP Jul 18, 2019

USCIS currently doesn't have TC, they only have base pay. TC would be better, but would require all applicants to submit new i140s.

Uber mH7bSe Jul 18, 2019

Just ask IRS. Problem solved.

LinkedIn I’mMe Jul 18, 2019

This problem is LC hard. I’m going to ask in design round.

Intel jcjz44 Jul 18, 2019

Why would employers sponser green cards if they want to pay dirt cheap.

Amazon acker OP Jul 18, 2019

They wouldn't. That's the point. Then there would be more greencards available for other employers who want to hire highly skilled people. Fewer cognizant petitions and more Intel ones.

Lyft TEHm35 Jul 18, 2019

Why not sort by cumulative taxes paid to the us government. The longer you are in the queue the more taxes you have paid the more you “deserve” to get a Green card. Again sort by this but you can also have a cutoff like eb5 . Let’s say when you get to 500k(inflation adjusted) of total tax paid you automatically qualify.

Intel jcjz44 Jul 18, 2019

This is equvatent to tc . You might as well say that.

Amazon acker OP Jul 18, 2019

I prefer the guy who paid 100k in one year over the guy who paid 10k for 10 years.

Veritas 13Jija Jul 19, 2019

Any idea when will it go to Senate for voting?

Google hooli.xyz Jul 19, 2019

It already went to the Senate and was immediately put on hold.

Micron bitline Jul 19, 2019

Add country quotas for h1bs and opts would be the best solution so system becomes balanced. Otherwise its obvious bottleneck. Opts are unlimited while ebs are limited.

Intel jcjz44 Jul 19, 2019

No best solution would be to limit F1.