Manager salary < Tech Individual Contributor?

This is the second time it had happened to me. I recently applied to two management positions: Senior BI Manager at Ameriprise Financial (Minneapolis) and Analytics Manager at Sears (Chicago). Both paying only $115K base + 10% bonus. That's lower than my current base which is ~130K (and 10% bonus) and I'm just a Lead BI developer at Target (Minneapolis) right now. Were those just outliers or is it more often? I understand Sears is not doing well but see no reason for AF.

eBay oldgrads May 31, 2019

Who says manager should earn more than ic does?

Amazon Pondering May 31, 2019

+1

Amazon YcUP73 Jun 1, 2019

Why DO managers earn more than devs, they barely do work

Target kgzots35 Jun 4, 2019

You probably have never been one, so thatโ€™s why you have no clue

TrueCar fl0dwk Jun 6, 2019

Because often managers do IC work in addition to project management, people management, and recruiting.

Walmart.com anothercat Jun 1, 2019

Sears is still hiring...?

Target Xxxyt Jun 1, 2019

Almost an year back

Sears QkAS13 Jun 6, 2019

No. They are only getting contactors.

Coupang ๐Ÿ’ฅ๐Ÿฆ–๐Ÿคท๐Ÿปโ€โ™‚๏ธ Jun 2, 2019

The reason you see this at Target in the Midwest is because Target is one of the highest paying employers in Minnesota / Twin Cities Area.

Target Xxxyt Jun 2, 2019

What other employers are highest paying?

Coupang ๐Ÿ’ฅ๐Ÿฆ–๐Ÿคท๐Ÿปโ€โ™‚๏ธ Jun 2, 2019

Target is the highest. BestBuy MAY be on part. But I donโ€™t think you can beat Target.

Target kgzots35 Jun 4, 2019

Yes...this

Target Tarzhay Jun 6, 2019

I've had ICs that made more than me, and they were worth it. Typically the mgr does make more though. There's a lot of accountability and burden that goes with the manager job, that's much less for most developer ICs.

CVS Health KWlK23 Jun 25, 2019

I worked for a manager that would not allow his employees to make more than him. He eventually realized that it was counterproductive. But I know of many people that still think that way. Also salary bands can be really wide at a lot of companies so perhaps they were trying to low-ball you.

Ameriprise Financial blIn66 Apr 14, 2023

๐Ÿคทโ€โ™‚๏ธ