Should I switch to a different company with same base but more reliable long term incentives?

Current company, late stage startup: 145k base 20k stock options, lowish strike price Company has had multiple rounds of layoffs so not sure how much those options will ever be worth Insurance premiums paid for Hybrid work New offer, cooperate backed startup: 145k base "Revenue share" model, so there will be a pool of money in 4 years where I would get .12% of. Insurance costs 2k per year 15k sign on bonus Remote first Not sure if I should move or not for the more reliable long term incentive. Thankful for any advice. Yoe: 2