Democrats: Support Tax on Unrealized Gains?

Biden has proposed taxing *unrealized* capital gains. (Currently, unrealized gains are not taxable.) Do you support this specific proposal? This question is for supporters of the US Democratic party.

Poll
233 Participants
Select only one answer
Amazon vastappan Apr 24

“1 Million “ …. So most of folks don’t care.

Stripe PapaBear2 Apr 24

12 years ago, a house sold for 1M in your Seattle area was seen as insanely expensive. Where are we now?

Amazon immy Apr 24

Telling me you are single and young without telling me you are single and young

DataRobot lolnoa Apr 24

before increasing taxes they should cut the spend

Snowflake RealOnion Apr 24

Yes, that’s why! It’s 1.5% of total spending, but of course you’ll end up living under the bridge only because of military aid to Ukraine, Israel and Taiwan.

Amazon oIFW35 Apr 26

I think Microsoft wants to go to war himself instead of people from these countries. Because we’re next if they fall.

PayPal ab8a4f6b Apr 24

TC > 1M? If it’s not auto-adjusted for inflation… it’s tricky because it requires future congresses to actually act.

Oyster mdgp36d Apr 25

It's Federal Property tax. That's the biggest unrealized gain. Family farmers easily have $1m in property they don't want to sell. This is a federal property grab, straight and simple.

Meta xdr56tyhnk Apr 25

@mdgp36d except that they already pay the property tax. Or rather they pay rent to the government.

Discord negative 0 Apr 24

This won't affect anyone on Blind. Why do you guys get so upset when taxes go up for people making over a million dollars a year? This proposal is not going after your Fidelity mutual fund account with $1 million invested for retirement. It's going after people who make millions of year in passive income and pay a lower average tax rate than those of us making 6 figures.

Google PuffleHuff OP Apr 24

Because it will certainly affect everyone indirectly. If others are taxed, it will affect how they allocate money and how they manage portfolios. Those follow-on changes will affect everyone. People with small incomes can figure this out and anticipate the changes.

Amazon Jk57slj Apr 24

Why not just choose a simple solution for the problem then? Instead of inventing a bunch of new bizarre laws that set dangerous precedent, tax all income the same. Simple and fair.

Splunk 🕊️onearth Apr 24

Stop spreading FUD. This won’t affect you - probably ever in your lifetime. Don’t fall for and spread propaganda

Google PuffleHuff OP Apr 24

If it is enacted, it will affect everyone indirectly.

Management Consulting Firm Rzlqp63 Apr 24

Absolutely incorrect, I’m probably far older than you so let me impart some wisdom. If this insane policy were to take effect, in time, the government would eventually move the goal posts and continuously include more and more people in the tax. This will 100% affect every single person who works or has assets to tax directly in time, this would be an eventual certainty.

Financial Services Company ColabaGirl Apr 24

Lol at OP with that billionaire mindset. 😂 People that are potentially affected by that already have citizenship abroad etc.

Google PuffleHuff OP Apr 24

So you anticipate that this will cause wealthy individuals to move money abroad, yet you don't worry about secondary effects of this.

Financial Services Company ColabaGirl Apr 24

Wealthy individuals aren’t paying their fair share. They have o. It is absolutely unfair that we mortals pay our fair share. It is absolutely unfair that a Wendy’s worker pays 15-45% of their income in taxes while billionaires pay zero. Some of them will move. Some of them will renounce American citizenship. This has happened in Europe. See Dyson, etc “moving” to SG. Yet you worry about them. In all likelihood you won’t be a billionaire.

Uber pizlleghe Apr 24

Most lowly Americans already pay tax on unrealized gains. I’ve been doing it since before I made six figures. It’s called property tax. Every year It increases on my home, an asset whose gains I don’t realize until I sell. Why is it fine for middle income Americans to pay it, and not the wealthiest among us?

Google PuffleHuff OP Apr 24

Very reasonable comment 👍

Capital One here4cap1 Apr 24

Somehow the government can say your house is now worth X and you're just supposed to pay taxes on that value now.

Amazon 4yxhe Apr 24

I don't see anything in this article that mentions taxes on unrealized gains --> https://www.forbes.com/newsletters/andrewleahey/2024/04/24/biden-capital-gains-rate-proposal-446/ Let me know if the article does mention it and I'm just blind and missed it.

Discord negative 0 Apr 24

It proposes a 25% AMT on income + unrealized capital gains for people with a wealth of over $100 million. And there would be a credit towards realized gains so you aren't getting taxed twice. It's really just like you're paying on the gains earlier.

Amazon 4yxhe Apr 24

You have a link to share where I can read more on this? The Forbes article I found makes no mention of 25%.

Autodesk yolo_gainz Apr 24

I’ll support it as long as I can claim all my unborn children in my balls as dependents

Amazon dIHb73 Apr 24

😂 , awesome! Unrealized dependents !

Oyster mdgp36d Apr 25

And all the Hispanics coming across the border should be declarable dependents.